Explosive Growth with Programmatic SEO (But Beware! 😱)

Today, we will talk about a topic that many are experimenting with, but few are mastering—Programmatic SEO. If you manage large websites or work in industries like e-commerce, SaaS, or affiliate marketing, chances are you’ve at least heard of this strategy. But does it really work? What are you gaining, and what could you lose? Let’s get straight to it.

What is Programmatic SEO?

It’s essentially scaling SEO by automating the creation of hundreds (or even thousands) of optimized pages, targeting long-tail keywords or specific search intents. You generate page templates programmatically and populate them with structured data—think location pages, product variations, or directory listings.

For example, instead of manually creating 500 pages for "Plumbers in {city_name}" you use automation to create all of them in seconds.

But is this genius, or is it a growth trap? Let’s examine the pros and cons.

The Pros of Programmatic SEO

1. Scale at Warp Speed 🚀
   With automation, you can produce hundreds (or thousands) of pages in the time it would take to write a few manually. This is ideal for websites with large datasets like marketplaces, SaaS websites, directories or geo-focused local businesses.

2. Dominate the Long-Tail
   Long-tail keywords can drive serious organic traffic because of their low competition. Programmatic SEO allows you to target multiple variations of long-tail queries across various niches or geographies, giving you more chances to rank.

3. Granular Targeting
   Create hyper-focused content for specific user intents. For instance, “best vegan restaurants in [City]” pages are infinitely scalable when the process is automated using a template.

4. Compounding Traffic
   If executed correctly, programmatically generated pages can lead to exponential traffic growth, building cumulative domain authority across all those pages.

5. Utility at Scale
   When combined with tools like Google Sheets, APIs, or data scrapers, you can generate endless useful information for your audience, such as product comparison tables, location-based guides, or statistical lists.

The Cons of Programmatic SEO

1. Risk of Thin Content 📉
   Algorithms like Google’s HCU (Helpful Content Update) can penalize sites for low-value or boilerplate content. Your programmatically generated pages might tank your rankings if they don’t deliver real value.

2. Duplicate Content Nightmares
   Without unique elements, many pages may end up being too similar to be considered valuable by search engines. This could lead to indexation issues or manual penalties.

3. High Maintenance
   Scaling initially feels great, but updating thousands of pages (especially if tied to APIs or external databases) can quickly become a logistical headache.

4. Crossing Google's Line?
   The “automation without value” approach could be harmful in the long run. Google regularly updates its guidelines to weed out low-quality, mass-produced content.

5. Quality Over Quantity Matters
   Programmatic pages still need optimization—internal links, schema, headings, and, most importantly, unique added value. Producing at scale often means sacrificing quality unless you have a bulletproof process.

6. Risk of Poor User Experience (UX)
   If too many automated pages are cookie-cutter, visitors may bounce. This signals to Google that your content doesn’t satisfy searcher intent.

Is It Worth It?

Programmatic SEO can be a game-changer, but only if done with precision and purpose. It’s not a shortcut—it’s a tool. To succeed, you should:

• Start small. Test on a subset of pages before scaling to your entire site.

• Ensure data accuracy. Your templates are only as good as the data that fuels them.

• Add value to every page. Include unique content, media, or user-centric features beyond just filling templates.

• Monitor performance. Use tools like Google Analytics and Search Console to track what works (and what doesn’t).

• Stay ethical. Just because you can create 100,000 pages doesn’t mean you should. Focus on the ones that matter most to your audience.

If you want to do pSEO correctly, and avoid the “Cons” I listed above, check out Practical Programmatic, an awesome course by Ian Nuttall that will help you learn the skills you need to drive traffic and sales using programmatic SEO.

If you are a developer or at least a little comfortable with code, the Programmatic SEO course + boilerplate bundle by Ilias Ism is another great option.

Remember, programmatic SEO isn’t the future for every site—but when executed smartly, it can supercharge growth for the right type of project.

Got questions or want to share your programmatic wins and fails? Drop me a reply—let’s geek out!

Until next time,
Roberto

P.S. Are you a local business that needs help with SEO? Reply to this email. Let’s chat.

Not a local business? No problem. I have many SEO freelancer friends I can recommend. Hit me up if you need an intro 🤝

Are there any specific topics you want me to cover in the coming weeks? Reply to this email and let me know!

If you found value in this email, please forward it to a friend and share it on social media.